A roadmap for schools to support the language(s) of schooling
Evaluation of the survey results
Sample school report
1. Presentation of the context
Our school wishes to support all our students to succeed. Therefore, we are looking for ways to help all learners
and especially vulnerable ones (i.e. students depending on the school to develop the language of schooling),
master the language used for teaching the various school subjects and for the functioning of the schools , i.e. "the
language of schooling". This can only be achieved if we manage to develop, collaboratively, a specific language
strategy that not only includes all school members but also the students and parents. Hence, if at all possible, it is
necessary for everybody working in the school to be aware of the current state of the practice and to take part in
the discussions in order to be able to commit to the different actions that should be implemented at different
levels.
The evaluation of the survey results below represents only one element to help us set up our strategy plan. The
European Centre for Modern Languages of the Council of Europe (ECML) recommends analysing and discussing
the survey results in order to identify the strengths of our school and the levers of progress. Based on the survey
data, this report highlights two areas relevant for further consideration in our school.
NB: the terms "areas" and
"dimensions" are terms frequently referred to in this report. Appendix 1 and 2 offer an overview and explanation of
all terms.
2. General results
24 participants took part in the self-assessment survey set up by our school:
3 teachers,
18 students,
3 parents/guardians,
evaluated the school according to a certain number of statements, organised
according to nine different areas. The spidergram below highlights the strengths and levers of progress, taking
into account all the answers from all the survey participants:
The spidergram enables us to have an overview of the results of ALL the stakeholders’ responses, thus
evaluating the school according to the nine areas listed below. We can easily see where our strengths and levers
of progress lay.
Please pay specific attention to these areas as they reveal a discrepancy among the stakeholders' responses.
The approaches and practices related to the “green areas” are well-established and evident in the day-to-day work of the school. They can be used as an example for other schools.
The approaches and practices related to the "yellow areas" have achieved a high level of implementation and
need only a little additional work to be exceptionally proficient.
The approaches and practices related to the "orange areas" are being developed but will need targeted support to
improve further.
The approaches and practices related to the "red areas" require attention and need to be developed urgently.
3. Our strengths
If we look at our strengths, we can see, for example, that the approaches and practices related to
Language resources at school and Professional development
have achieved a high level of implementation and need only a little additional work to be exceptionally
proficient.
-
Language resources at school means knowing about the languages of the students, staff and
families, and knowing when and how to use them to facilitate the students’ integration.
-
Professional development means having the structures for planning and reviewing the teachers’
competences, developing their awareness and cooperation, and creating and supporting
professional learning communities inside the school. This area can, for example, include actionresearch, collaborative learning, etc.
4. Our levers of progress
In order to start our discussion regarding the ways to help our school better take into account the language(s) of
schooling, we could look into two areas, for instance
Promoting informal language learning and Attitudes towards languages.
- Promoting informal language learning
The approaches and practices related to
Promoting informal language learning
may not have received enough attention and
need to be developed.
Promoting informal language learning means supporting the opportunities for students’ informal
language learning and their language development at home.
To assist in our discussions, we can look at the following promising practices set up in different European
countries and beyond. They may help us start thinking about practical ideas to adapt to our own context.
Opportunities for informal language learning
Supporting students' language development at home
The ROADMAP database of promising practices contains more examples related to Promoting informal language learning.
- Attitudes towards languages
The approaches and practices related to
Attitudes towards languages
may not have received enough attention and
need to be developed.
Attitudes towards languages means valuing students' languages, and tracking their individual
literacy development. This area also recognizes the importance of plurilingual approaches and the
way languages are visible in the school environment.
To assist in our discussions, we can look at the following promising practices set up in different European
countries and beyond. They may help us start thinking about practical ideas to adapt to our own context.
Promoting plurilingualism
Displaying plurilingualism in the school environment
Valuing students' languages
Tracking literacy development
The ROADMAP database of promising practices contains more examples related to Attitudes towards languages.
DELETE EVERYTHING UNTIL SECTION 5
Attitudes towards languages means valuing students' languages, and tracking their individual
literacy development. This area also recognizes the importance of plurilingual approaches and the
way languages are visible in the school environment.
UNDEFINED: index4-text3
[name of dimension 1 in this principle]
- Promising practice 1: [name of promising practice 1 in this dimension]
- Promising practice 2: [name of promising practice 2 in this dimension]
[name of dimension 2 in this principle]
- Promising practice 1: [name of promising practice 1 in this dimension]
- Promising practice 2: [name of promising practice 2 in this dimension]
UNDEFINED: index4-text4 [principle name]:
www.ecml.at/roadmap-[ID of principle]
END DELETE
5. Areas that require our special attention
One area shows a discrepancy between the opinions of different stakeholders, indicated by the emoticon. Let’s look more closely at this situations in order to try and understand the origin of such a discrepancy.
- Discrepancy in Promoting informal language learning
Promoting informal language learning means supporting the opportunities for students’ informal
language learning and their language development at home.
The table below enables us to see to what extent the different stakeholders who participated in the survey agree on the way Promoting informal language learning is taken into account in our school:
|
Very little or not at all
|
To a certain extent
|
To a satisfactory extent
|
To a great extent
|
student
|
29.41%
|
23.53%
|
17.65%
|
29.41%
|
parent
|
60.00%
|
20.00%
|
0.00%
|
20.00%
|
teacher
|
0.00%
|
0.00%
|
75.00%
|
25.00%
|
It seems that various stakeholders hold different views on the way Promoting informal language learning is taken into account. We may therefore need to set up opportunities to discuss this with the other stakeholders in order to understand the discrepancy and/or to develop this area.
DELETE START
Some areas show a discrepancy between the opinions of different stakeholders, indicated by the emoticon.
Let’s look more closely at two of the situations in order to try and understand the origin of such a discrepancy.
or
One area shows a discrepancy between the opinions of different stakeholders, indicated by the emoticon. Let’s look more closely at this situations in order to try and understand the origin of such a discrepancy.
or
No areas show a discrepancy between the opinions of different stakeholders.
DELETE END
6. Conclusion
More data and charts resulting from the self-assessment survey are available online in the coordinator’s area. However, we have already become aware of some of our strengths and levers of progress and have been able to identify some discrepancies of opinions and perceptions between the main stakeholders in our school. Based on the main results of the survey summarised in this report we can now set up our own language strategy.
Appendix 1. List of areas and dimensions
Areas |
Dimensions |
Attitudes towards languages |
-
Promoting plurilingualism
-
Displaying plurilingualism in the school environment
-
Valuing students' languages
-
Tracking literacy development
|
Awareness of language dimension |
-
Emphasis on language learning
-
Being language models
-
Importance of challenging activities
|
Developing language knowledge and skills |
-
Teaching specificities of language
-
Awareness of spoken and written language
-
Improving speaking and writing skills
-
Improving listening and reading skills
|
Promoting informal language learning |
-
Opportunities for informal language learning
-
Supporting students' language development at home
|
Language resources at school |
-
Knowledge about the students' languages
-
Knowledge about the staff's languages
-
Knowledge about the families' language
|
Role of language in learning |
-
Plurilingualism during lessons
-
Bridging languages for learning
-
Building upon previous knowledge and experience
-
Importance of language in subject teaching
-
Promoting language development
|
Metalinguistic awareness |
-
Language dimension in subject teaching
-
Language-related concepts
|
Orienting newcomer students and families |
-
Making use of language resources at school
-
Professional resources for communication
-
Community resources for communication with parents/guardians
-
Key documents in different languages
|
Professional development |
-
Professional learning communities
-
Structures for professional development
-
Planning and reviewing
-
Developing teachers' awareness
-
Cooperation among teachers
|
Appendix 2. Explanations of the areas
Awareness of language dimension means putting an emphasis on language learning in general,
understanding the importance of being language models (for the whole staff), and giving the
students challenging activities
Developing language knowledge and skills means that the teachers focus on the specificities of language in their teaching, increase the students’ awareness of spoken and written language, and improve constantly their speaking/writing and listening/reading skills.
Metalinguistic awareness means taking into account the language dimension in subject teaching
and exploring/learning language-related concepts, whatever the subject, to help learners
understand and use content more easily.
Role of languages in learning means that the importance of language in subject teaching is
recognised, and students’ language development is promoted. It means also using the advantages
of plurilingualism during lessons, bridging languages for learning, and building upon students’
previous knowledge and experiences
Attitudes towards languages means valuing students' languages, and tracking their individual
literacy development. This area also recognizes the importance of plurilingual approaches and the
way languages are visible in the school environment.
Promoting informal language learning means supporting the opportunities for students’ informal
language learning and their language development at home.
Language resources at school means knowing about the languages of the students, staff and
families, and knowing when and how to use them to facilitate the students’ integration.
Orienting newcomer students and families means supporting the newcomers by using the language
resources of the school environment, including both the professional and community resources for
communication. This could be, e.g. producing the necessary key documents in different languages.
Professional development means having the structures for planning and reviewing the teachers’
competences, developing their awareness and cooperation, and creating and supporting
professional learning communities inside the school. This area can, for example, include actionresearch, collaborative learning, etc.
|
This is an output of the project “A roadmap for schools to support the
language(s) of schooling” (2017-2019) of the European Centre for Modern
Languages (ECML). The ECML is a Council of Europe institution promoting
excellence in language education in its member states.
www.ecml.at/roadmapforschools
|